How medical communication affects malpractice cases
Introduction
The lack of effective communication in healthcare is currently recognized not only as a barrier to quality care but as one of the main causes of medical malpractice. Proper information transfer between doctor and patient is crucial for preventing serious errors, correctly developing informed consent, and establishing effective therapeutic measures.
Legal definition of medical malpractice
Medical malpractice occurs when a healthcare professional acts outside the required standards, causing preventable harm to the patient. This breach can lead to civil, criminal, and disciplinary liability, especially when there is evidence that information was not adequately transmitted, documented, or understood (Source: Wikipedia, Spanish health law).
Informed consent and its relation to communication
One of the central pillars in the doctor-patient relationship is informed consent. Spanish jurisprudence and that of numerous countries consider that for consent to be valid, it must be preceded by a clear explanation of the diagnosis, therapeutic alternatives, risks, expected benefits, and possible consequences (Source: recent judgments on defective informed consent).
A defective informed consent—due to lack, absence of relevant information, ambiguities, or use of incomprehensible technical language for the patient—is one of the main sources of malpractice claims. Courts require documentary evidence that the information was adequate and personalized.
Real cases of medical malpractice due to poor communication
Lack of information or poor transmission can have devastating consequences. For example, recently:
- Clinical case judged in Madrid (2021): Four doctors were convicted by the Provincial Court of Madrid for confusing a stroke with depression in a 36-year-old patient due to incomplete medical evaluation and poor communication between professionals. This internal communication error led to a delay in diagnosis and, therefore, severe and preventable neurological damage to the patient (Source: national press).
- Medication errors: Some cases documented in legal literature show that many prescription errors, overdoses, or administration of wrong medications can be traced back to inadequate explanation to the patient or family, especially when there are language or cultural barriers.
Impact on the legal defense of the doctor
From a legal perspective, the absence of records demonstrating communication with the patient greatly weakens the healthcare professional's defense against a claim. Not documenting the delivery of information, the patient's understanding of it, or the confirmation of their freedom of choice opens the door to unfavorable judgments, even when the medical action was technically correct.
Practical consequences and recommendations
For the patient
- Higher risk of harm: Lack of communication increases the risk of adverse effects, complications, and missed therapeutic opportunities.
- Legal vulnerability: Without sufficient information, the patient cannot make informed health decisions or adequately exercise their autonomy.
For the healthcare professional
- Risk of lawsuits and sanctions: Judicial statistics prove that over 60% of malpractice claims originate from lack of information or the perception of disregard or lack of empathy.
- Reputation and increased liability: Disciplinary records for poor communication can lead to fines to professional disqualification.
Essential best practices
- Systematic use of clear, personalized, and documented informed consent models.
- Verbal explanation reinforced with written materials for the patient.
- Records in the medical history about the informative process and resolved doubts.
- Continuous training in communication skills and conflict management.
Conclusion
Adequate communication is not only an ethical tool but a true legal shield against possible medical malpractice situations. Ensuring bidirectional, adapted, and personalized information channels for each patient is the best strategy to prevent claims and, above all, to provide excellent healthcare.
Need specialized advice on medical malpractice cases?
Schedule an appointment with our expert legal team in health law and defend your rights with the utmost guarantee.